Alex Soojung-Kim Pang, Ph.D.

I study people, technology, and the worlds they make

Month: July 2005 (page 1 of 5)

It’s out! (Michael Chorost’s Rebuilt)

My review of Michael Chorost's Rebuilt : How Becoming Part Computer Made Me More Human is on the L.A. Times Web site. I think it's also the lead review, but I haven't seen hard copy yet; I've got a couple copies reserved at my local bookstore.

Unlike my review of More Than Human : Embracing the Promise of Biological Enhancement, I actually found this one myself.

Update, 9 December 2011: Since the review doesn't seem to be available on the L. A. Times Web site, I've posted it below.

Human meaning in a world of ones and zeroes

Michael Chorost, Rebuilt: How Becoming Part Computer Made Me More Human. Houghton Mifflin: 224 pp., $24

By Alex Soojung-Kim Pang, Alex Soojung-Kim Pang is a research director at the Institute for the Future, a Silicon Valley think tank; and the author of "Empire and the Sun: Victorian Solar Eclipse Expeditions."

In July 2001, Michael Chorost, a writer and researcher at SRI International, a Silicon Valley research center, became deaf after a viral illness. That fall, he became a cyborg. "I can feel the compact bulk of the implant in my skull," Chorost writes about the surgery. "It is strange to think that by now its two computer chips will have warmed up to exactly the temperature of my body."

Chorost's hearing had been impaired since childhood. When he was 36, while on a business trip to Nevada, he noticed that both his hearing aids were failing. Nothing he did — a change of batteries, adjusting ear molds and tubes — made a difference. In a local emergency room, a specialist told him what was happening to his hearing. "I've always been hard of hearing. I can't go deaf," he thought.

In a normally functioning ear, sound waves are translated into electrical impulses by thousands of tiny hairs in the cochlea, a spiral organ linking the ear to the brain. The hairs in Chorost's cochleas no longer functioned, but the nerves that connected them to the brain were undamaged. Thus, he was a candidate for a cochlear implant, an electronic device that digitally processes sounds and transmits them to 16 electrodes connected to the cochlear nerves.

"Rebuilt: How Becoming Part Computer Made Me More Human" is Chorost's account of learning to hear again. Funny and thoughtful, the book is an extended meditation on the nature of perception, the human brain and the relationship between technology and humanity.

The term "cyborg" is familiar from science fiction. Think of TV's Steve Austin, "the bionic man," or characters on "Star Trek." Some even use the term when referring to any combination of humans and machines: By this standard, someone wearing glasses or even using a toothbrush is a cyborg. Wrong, Chorost argues: To be a cyborg, you need technology that "exerts control of some kind over the body." In his case, the cochlear implant mediates between him and the world of sound; he hears through a tangle of silicon, wire and code.

The implant is the size and thickness of two quarters: Packed into its ceramic casing are a microprocessor, a radio transmitter and a magnet that externally attach to a headpiece worn by Chorost. An insulated wire from the microprocessor is threaded into the cochlea. "The computer's playing my ear," he writes about the time it was first activated. Sixteen electrodes don't produce the same signals that thousands of hairs do. Autumn leaves tinkle rather than crunch. Leaf blowers and toilets sound like explosions. And the implant seems to make little distinction between sounds that are near and far. Chorost must learn to interpret the new signals.

Some of this learning is conscious: Conversations are easier if he doesn't concentrate too hard on them. Much of it happens at the neural level, as Chorost's brain learns to associate new signals with familiar sounds like friends' voices or the rustling of paper. Male and female voices at first sound the same, muffled and indistinct. But then they begin to sound different; eventually, "male voices sounded deep" once more and "women sounded like women again." What happened?

"My brain had somehow reinterpreted a huge frequency change back into a semblance of normality," he explains.

Incredibly, the implant uses two software programs to control the electrodes, which interpret sound in very different ways. One program makes the world sound "big, blocky and fuzzy," he writes, while the other makes the world sound quiet, metallic and tinny. Different programs produce different auditory worlds, and different realities.

"My hearing had not been restored," he writes. "It had been replaced, with an entirely new system that had entirely new rules…. I would have to become emotionally open to what I heard, instead of fighting against it."

The challenge of making human meaning in a world of zeroes and ones colors other parts of Chorost's life too, including his attitude toward technology. He signs up for online dating services but finds that the reduction of people to a set of formal coordinates — height, eye color, profession — may suggest precise matchmaking when it actually short-circuits the slow, serendipitous processes that normally bring and bind people together. (Ellen Ullman's classic memoir, "Close to the Machine: Technophilia and Its Discontents," also describes the effect of technological obsession on private passion.)

In one brilliant passage, Chorost notes that "[s]ocial norms are not taught, they are overheard, but the one thing even the most skilled deaf people cannot do is overhear." And yet, the deaf community in America is a group whose "warmth, intimacy, and cohesiveness … are legendary," and whose members have turned American Sign Language into a remarkably expressive medium. (Chorost was never quite part of that world: He responded to hearing aids, and his parents were determined to raise him in the hearing world rather than have him learn to sign.) Cochlear implants are available to many young deaf children today. Those who get them won't hear perfectly but they probably won't learn enough sign language to be full members of the deaf community: In other words, they'll be like Chorost. In the long run, the author fears, cochlear implants will probably spell the deaf community's end — yet another community whose bonds will be weakened, or destroyed, by technology.

Four years after getting the implant, Chorost has decamped suburban Silicon Valley for urban San Francisco, and he continues his search for the ideal mate. He also hears pretty well. But even more important, as he reflects on the equipment and the software that runs it, he says, "my bionic hearing made me more human, because I was constantly aware that my perception of the universe was provisional, the result of human decisions that would be revised time and again. [I]t was my task as a human being to strive to connect ever more complexly and deeply with the people and places of my life."

"Rebuilt" may be the first of a new genre: the cyborg memoir. It certainly won't be the last. Every era has its characteristic trials and transformations. Thanks to a blend of demographics and technological advance, we can expect an avalanche of stories of transformations that are equal parts technological, neurological and social. Futurist Theodore Roszak argues in "Longevity Revolution" that aging baby boomers will embrace a stunning variety of implants and genetic modifications to remain healthy and independent.

Medical advances are improving formerly life-threatening medical conditions brought on by advancing age or injury. What was once a rare or easily marginalized experience may become a rite of passage as millions of us, entering our last decades, learn to walk, see or hear again. The challenge will not just be to recover but to draw what wisdom we can from the experience.

Chorost shows us the way. His awareness of life's fragility, gained after making a determined effort to overcome its challenges, strikes me as the perfect answer to opponents of implants and genetic modification who worry about the effect of such tinkerings on our selves and souls. Memoirs such as "Rebuilt" will be invaluable guides in this new territory.

[To the tune of Barbie, "How Can I Refuse?," from the album "Barbie Sings!: The Princess Movie Song Collection".]

Technorati Tags: books, Rebuilt

Children’s books, the original new media

I was in graduate school during the French Invasion- the period when the works of Foucault, Derrida, Lacan, Baudrillard, and other French theorists became amazingly popular (and eventually controversial) among American social science and humanities academics.

Even though I was in a department that considered itself pretty cutting-edge and out there, I read only a sliver of that literature. One of the central claims that people tended to take away from writers like Derrida was that everything was a text- the book, the shirt, the coffee table, reality, the whole enchilada- and thus could be understood using the tools of literary theory.

Deconstruction has been subject to plenty of critiques, but one thing always stood out for me: while literary theory made grand claims for the universality of texts, the texts upon which literary theory was built- the ones that served as the empirical data that the theory was supposed to explain- were pretty narrow. When people talked about “texts,” they mainly had “scholarly books” in mind.

For some time, I’ve wondered what a literary theory built upon children’s books would look like. What would your theory of the text be like if you had to account for texts that were machine-washable, designed to repel drool, had moving parts, or fur and perfume (think of Pat the Bunny)? Could one speak so confidently about the linearity of a text when it has a little bookmark with a stuffed animal on it that you Velcro to the pages? Do arguments about the passiveness of “the reader” hold up when the book is read aloud by one person to another, and that other person might try to bite the book?

I was reminded of these questions again last week when I took my children to a bookstore, and my son found this:

It’s from a local publisher, Klutz Books, which does a lot of children’s and activity books. It’s a book- or a collection of books- designed to be read by children on car trips. In fact, it’s designed to fit in a cup holder- by far the healthiest use of cup holders I’ve seen in a while.

For anyone who can’t read it, the contents are listed as “4 activity books for the road. 160 pages of puzzles, games, dot-to-dots, tricks, trivia, magic, mazes, jokes, doodles…”

Obviously, in one sense it’s not a book. Yet it’s sold in a bookstore, and you’re supposed to do recognizably book-related things with it (for parents, the most important of those things is sit still and be quiet). It’s a text. But does it have a theory that can adequately explain it?

Of course, hornbooks and chapbooks were innovative artifacts in their day- meaning the Renaissance. Books for children have long been on the margins of publishing, but in interesting ways. Today, you’ve got children’s books that fit in cup-holders; books that almost read themselves to you; books that you’re supposed to read, but also manipulate, stretch, view through funny glasses, and the like. You have to wonder if there are some reading practices that will develop in this wonderfully heterogeneous, deeply physical form of literature, and will seriously affect the ways we read- and the ways we think about what texts are.

Technorati Tags: books, children, media, postacademic, reading

Fuji Crosstown Corsstown???

This morning, I took my son to the bike store. We passed this line of Fuji Crosstown bikes in front. Then I looked a little closer at them. Something was wrong.

How the heck did this get past quality control?

And what else might have slipped through? It makes you wonder.

Technorati Tags: bicycles, humor, Silicon Valley

You want fries with that?

The relentless, indefatigable American desire to invent and innovate lives on!:

If you like your fries with your drive, this is a device for you

In this age of over-the-top convenience, you know you’re in trouble if you would seriously consider an item like this.

It’s called the French Fry Holder by Copco, and it converts car cup holders into larger containers to keep fries close to you and upright to prevent spills. The device will accommodate small to obesity-bound servings.

There’s even a small clip-on slot for ketchup to make dipping fries a breeze. I’d written off dipping while driving long ago because of the mess factor.

[via Jason]

[To the tune of Guns N’ Roses, “Live And Let Die,” from the album “Use Your Illusion I“.]

Technorati Tags: humor, manufacturing, mobility

The worst joke I’ve ever heard

From one of my interns:

So, an HTTP request walks into a bar and asks for a drink. And the bartender looks it up and down, and points to a sign that says “Server not responding.”

Not exactly “the Aristocrats,” but that’s just as well.

Technorati Tags: humor, IFTF, internet

No iPod store!

Yesterday, we went walking along University Avenue after dinner. We walked by the Apple Store, which the kids always like to visit- apparently my son has an intuitive sense for fractal marketing- but it was closed for renovation.



from Flickr

They were not pleased.

And yes, the picture is posed. But they were disappointed.

Technorati Tags: applestore, children, paloalto

The story of the CPR dummy

This week’s New Scientist has a strange, fascinating story of how a famous death mask- from a young woman who drowned in the Seine a century ago- became the model for CPR dummies. I think it’s open to nonsubscribers.

[To the tune of Johann Sebastian Bach, “Passacaglia in C Minor, BWV 582,” from the album “The Art of Fugue Vol. 2”.]

Technorati Tags: history, memory, science

The world is not enough

Now, Google Moon.

Don’t forget to zoom all the way in.

[via Salon]

[To the tune of Al Stewart, “Time Passages,” from the album “The Best of Al Stewart“.]

Technorati Tags: humor, internet, search

Guess-the-Google

This is serious fun (discovered via Fred’s House).

Basically, it returns thumbnails from a one-word Google Images search. You have twenty seconds to guess what word was used to build that search.

This is part of the same category of phenomenon as Google Map hacks, and whose significance is explained here by Barney Pell: an example of what begins to be possible “when online data plays well together.”

At last year’s NPUC conference, I remember Brewster Kahle saying that he looked forward to the day when it would be possible to create something as interesting as Google every month. Maybe we’re drawing incrementally closer to that dream.

[To the tune of Stan Harrison, “Simply Depression, My Dear,” from the album “The Ties That Blind“.]

Technorati Tags: innovation, internet, visualization

Note to self: Get more interns

I’ve had a couple interns working at the Institute this summer, and have really enjoyed having them around. But I’ve got a long way to go before I red-line the system. This from DCeiver’s recent visit to Capitol Hill:

Hillary has an army of fifty interns. Fifty! That’s like, three kickball teams. And they share SIX computers! They must get a lot of zen gardening done. I call them the Clinterns.

[To the tune of Led Zeppelin, “I Can’t Quit You Baby,” from the album “Led Zeppelin (Disc 1)”.]

Technorati Tags: IFTF

Older posts

© 2017 Alex Soojung-Kim Pang, Ph.D.

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑